Shumway Insurance Agency | Auto Insurance in Holbrook, AZ

About Us

Founded in 1969, Shumway Insurance Agency has been a trusted, family‑owned insurance partner for the Holbrook community for more than five decades. Operated by Debbie and David Shumway, the agency’s mission is simple: provide personalized protection that fits each client’s lifestyle and budget. Their long‑standing presence, combined with a 4.9‑star rating from Liberty Mutual customers, demonstrates a commitment to honesty, responsiveness, and local expertise.

Insurance Services Offered

We serve individuals, families, and businesses with a full suite of insurance products:

• Auto Insurance – liability, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist coverage.
• Home Insurance – dwelling, personal property, liability, and flood endorsement options.
• Life Insurance – term, whole life, and universal life policies to protect loved ones.
• Business Insurance – commercial property, general liability, workers’ compensation, and professional liability.

Why Choose Us

Choosing an insurance partner is about more than price. Here’s why Holbrook residents keep coming back:

• Local Experience: Over 50 years serving the Navajo County area.
• Independent Agency: We work with multiple carriers, giving you true choice.
• High Customer Satisfaction: 4.9‑star rating reflects prompt claims help and friendly service.
• Family‑Focused Service: Debbie and David personally oversee each policy to ensure it meets your unique needs.

Our Carriers

Shumway Insurance Agency partners with a broad network of reputable carriers. While specific carrier names are disclosed during the quote process, clients benefit from the agency’s ability to compare rates and coverage options from leading insurers, ensuring the best value and protection.

Service Area

We are licensed to provide insurance throughout Arizona, with a primary focus on Holbrook and the surrounding Navajo County communities. ⚠️ Please confirm exact coverage zones by contacting the agency directly.

Getting a Quote

Obtaining a free, no‑obligation quote is quick and easy:

1. Visit our website at shumwayinsurance.com and fill out the online quote form.
2. Call us directly at (928) 524‑6600 to speak with an agent.
3. Stop by our office at 538 W Hopi Dr, Holbrook, AZ 86025 during business hours for an in‑person consultation.

All quotes are free, and we’ll walk you through each coverage option so you can make an informed decision.

Claims Support

When a claim arises, we act as your advocate:

• Immediate assistance 24/7 via phone.
• Guidance on documentation and filing procedures.
• Coordination with the carrier to expedite settlement.

Our goal is to make the claims process as stress‑free as possible, letting you focus on recovery.

Meet Our Team

Debbie Shumway – Co‑owner and senior agent with deep knowledge of personal and commercial lines. Debbie’s hands‑on approach ensures every policy is tailored to the client’s risk profile.

David Shumway – Co‑owner and underwriting specialist. David leverages his extensive network of carriers to secure competitive rates for both auto and business policies.

Client Testimonials

“Shumway Insurance helped us find the perfect home policy after a recent move. Their agents were patient and explained every detail.” – Local homeowner

“Fast, friendly service and a great rate on our fleet insurance. The 4.9‑star rating is well deserved.” – Small‑business owner

FAQs

💬 What types of insurance can I bundle for a discount?

You can combine auto, home, and business policies to qualify for multi‑policy discounts, which often lower your overall premium.

💬 How long does the quote process take?

Most quotes are prepared within 24‑48 hours after we receive the necessary information.

💬 Do you offer online policy management?

Yes, clients can access their policies, make payments, and request changes through our secure online portal.

💬 What is the agency’s state insurance license number?

License Number: ⚠️ Please contact the agency directly to confirm.

💬 Can I get coverage if I have a high‑risk driving record?

Our independent status allows us to shop multiple carriers, increasing the chance of finding a suitable high‑risk auto policy.

Ready to protect what matters most? Call (928) 524‑6600 or visit our website for a free quote today.

Editorial review: June 17, 2026 — Sources: shumwayinsurance.com, agency.nationwide.com, agents.libertymutual.com, yelp.com, facebook.com. If you notice any inaccurate data, please report it.