Poppell Insurance — Insurance in Plant City | Car Insurance

🏢 About Poppell Insurance, Inc.

Poppell Insurance, Inc. is a well-established, family-owned independent insurance agency dedicated to serving the Plant City community and the state of Florida. Founded in 1964 by Tom Poppell and Red Harrell, the agency has built a legacy of trust and reliability over the past 50+ years. Following the acquisition of the Moody and Moody Group in 1996, the agency continued to expand its capabilities. Today, the agency is led by Tom’s sons, Mark Poppell and Jon Poppell, who uphold the tradition of personalized service and integrity.

As an independent agency, Poppell Insurance is not tied to a single insurance carrier. This independence allows them to shop around on behalf of their clients, comparing policies and prices from multiple reputable providers to find the best fit for individual needs. The agency prides itself on its long-tenured staff, many of whom have been with the company for years, ensuring that clients receive consistent and knowledgeable support every time they call or visit.

Licensing Information: Poppell Insurance, Inc. is a licensed insurance agency in the State of Florida (License NPN # 102622, LIFE # A209661).

🛡️ What Insurance Services Are Available?

Poppell Insurance offers a comprehensive suite of insurance solutions designed to protect individuals, families, and businesses. While they specialize in specific areas, their independent status allows them to address a wide variety of coverage needs.

⚠️ Based on the carriers represented, the agency likely offers Auto, Home, and Business insurance in addition to the specialties listed below. Please confirm by contacting the business directly.

• Health Insurance: Navigating the complex world of healthcare can be difficult. The agency helps clients find health insurance plans that provide the right balance of coverage and cost, whether for individuals, families, or seniors.
• Life Insurance: Securing the financial future of loved ones is a priority. Poppell Insurance offers various life insurance options, including term and whole life policies, to ensure peace of mind and long-term financial stability.
• Insurance Solutions: Beyond standard policies, the agency provides general insurance solutions tailored to unique client situations, including policy reviews and coverage adjustments.
• Claims Filing & Support: In the event of a loss, the agency assists clients with the claims filing process, advocating on their behalf to ensure a fair and timely resolution.
• Policy Management: Clients receive support with bill payment, policy changes, and answering questions regarding their existing coverage.

⭐ Why Choose Poppell Insurance?

Choosing the right insurance agency is just as important as choosing the right policy. Poppell Insurance stands out for several key reasons that prioritize the client’s experience and financial security.

• Independent Agency Advantage: They work for you, not the insurance company. By representing multiple carriers, they can objectively compare options to find you the best rate and coverage.
• Decades of Experience: With over 50 years in business, the agency has deep roots in the community and extensive knowledge of the insurance landscape in Florida.
• Personalized Service: As a family-owned business, they treat clients like neighbors. You get a dedicated team that knows your history and your specific needs, rather than a call center representative.
• Trusted Carriers: They partner with financially strong and reputable insurance companies, ensuring that your claims will be paid and your assets are protected.
• Local Expertise: Located in Plant City, they understand the specific risks and insurance requirements relevant to Florida residents.

🏢 What Carriers Does Poppell Insurance Represent?

Poppell Insurance has partnered with a diverse group of top-tier insurance carriers to provide a wide array of options. Some of the reputable carriers they represent include:

• AmTrust
• Auto-Owners
• CNA / CNA Surety
• FCCI
• Great American
• Main St. America
• Markel
• Philadelphia
• Progressive
• Tower Hill
• Travelers

📍 Service Area

While their physical office is located in Plant City, Poppell Insurance serves clients throughout the entire state of Florida. Whether you are located in Hillsborough County or a neighboring county, their team is equipped to assist with your insurance needs via phone, email, or in-person consultations.

📝 How Can I Get a Quote?

Obtaining a quote is simple and straightforward. Poppell Insurance offers multiple ways for potential clients to get started:

1. Phone: Call their office directly at (813) 752-4155 to speak with an agent who can provide an immediate quote or schedule a consultation.
2. Website: Visit www.poppellinsurance.com to learn more about their services and request information online.
3. In-Person: Stop by their office at 503 W Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Blvd., Plant City, FL 33563, Monday through Friday, between 8:00 am and 5:00 pm.

🛠️ Claims Support

Filing an insurance claim can be stressful. The team at Poppell Insurance is committed to making the process as smooth as possible. They guide clients through every step of the claims filing process, from documenting the damage to communicating with the insurance carrier adjusters. Their goal is to ensure that clients receive the fair compensation they are entitled to under their policies.

👥 Meet Our Team

The agency is staffed by a team of experienced professionals dedicated to customer service. Key members of the team include:

• Mark Poppell & Jon Poppell: Owners leading the agency with a focus on community and client relationships.
• Support Staff: Caden Hogue, Patricia Lyons, Belinda Veloz, Melissa Lawrence, Linda Buck, Judie Chapman, Grace Gainer, Kristina Pilla, Rachael Walls, Evon McDonald, and Jon Thomas Poppell.

The longevity of the staff members is a testament to the agency’s positive work environment and dedication to client retention.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

What are the office hours?
Poppell Insurance is open Monday through Friday from 8:00 am to 5:00 pm. They are closed on weekends.

Do they offer online bill payment?
Yes, the agency assists clients with bill payment and policy management. Check their website or call the office for specific portal access or payment instructions.

Can I change my policy mid-term?
Yes, the agents at Poppell Insurance can help you adjust your coverage, add drivers, or make other changes to your existing policy.

Why should I use an independent agent?
An independent agent like Poppell Insurance can compare rates and coverages from multiple companies (like Progressive, Travelers, and Auto-Owners) simultaneously, saving you time and potentially money.

Editorial review: June 9, 2026 — Sources: biltmoreins.com, facebook.com, linkedin.com, business.plantcity.org, yelp.com. If you notice any inaccurate data, please report it.