Ferguson & McGuire Insurance Inc. — Auto Insurance in East

🏢 About Us

Ferguson & McGuire Insurance Inc. has been a trusted name in Connecticut’s insurance landscape since 1938. As an independent broker, the agency proudly serves both personal and commercial clients across the state, offering tailored coverage solutions that prioritize protection, affordability, and peace of mind. With deep roots in East Hartford and multiple branches throughout Connecticut, they’ve built a reputation for reliability, professionalism, and client-centered service.

As one of the longest-standing independent agencies in the region, Ferguson & McGuire emphasizes risk assessment, client education, and ongoing policy review. They are licensed in Connecticut and represent top-tier carriers, ensuring clients receive competitive quotes and comprehensive protection. Their approach goes beyond transactions — they aim to be a lifelong partner in managing risk and safeguarding assets.

🛡️ What Types of Insurance Do They Offer?

Ferguson & McGuire provides a full spectrum of personal and commercial insurance services designed to meet diverse needs. Whether you’re a homeowner, driver, business owner, or specialized professional, they have coverage options tailored to your situation.

• Auto Insurance – Protection for personal and commercial vehicles, including multi-car and high-mileage drivers.
• Home Insurance – Coverage for homeowners, renters, condos, and dwelling fire policies.
• Umbrella Insurance – Extra liability protection beyond standard policies.
• Boat & Motorcycle Insurance – Specialized coverage for recreational vehicles.
• Commercial Insurance – Business Owner’s Policy (BOP), general liability, commercial property, and commercial auto.
• Workers’ Compensation – Mandatory coverage for employees, compliant with CT regulations.
• Professional Liability – Also known as errors and omissions insurance for consultants and engineers.
• Niche Market Coverage – Custom policies for contractors, arborists, auto body shops, and engineers.

All policies are customizable, and the agency offers free consultations to help clients understand their options.

✅ Why Choose Ferguson & McGuire Insurance?

With over 88 years in business, Ferguson & McGuire stands out for its independence, expertise, and commitment to service. As an independent broker, they are not tied to a single carrier, allowing them to shop multiple top-rated insurers to find the best fit for each client. This flexibility leads to more competitive rates and better coverage alignment.

They offer online services including video meetings, eSignatures, and virtual policy reviews, making it easy to manage insurance from anywhere. The agency also provides free consultations and online quotes, ensuring transparency and convenience. Clients consistently describe the team as “like family,” praising their responsiveness and professionalism.

🤝 Which Insurance Carriers Do They Work With?

Ferguson & McGuire partners with nationally recognized, financially stable carriers to ensure reliable coverage and claims support. Their primary affiliations include:

• Nationwide – Known for customer service and flexible policies.
• Travelers – A leader in commercial and personal insurance with strong financial ratings.
• The Andover Companies – Specializes in property and casualty insurance for unique risks.

By representing multiple carriers, they can compare options and recommend the best value for your needs.

📍 Service Area

Ferguson & McGuire is licensed to operate in Connecticut and primarily serves clients across the state. Their East Hartford office is located at 45 Connecticut Boulevard, East Hartford, CT 06108, and they also maintain additional branches to support local communities. They specialize in both urban and rural risk profiles, including niche industries like arboriculture and contracting.

Connecticut insurance license number: CT-licensed independent agency.

📞 How Can I Get a Free Quote?

Getting a quote from Ferguson & McGuire is fast, free, and easy. You can:

• Call (860) 572-5908 to speak with a licensed agent.
• Visit their website at fergusonmcguire.com to request an online quote.
• Schedule a virtual appointment via video meeting for personalized service from home or office.
• Visit the East Hartford office in person during business hours.

They offer free policy reviews and multi-policy discounts, including up to 15% off home insurance when bundled with auto.

🆘 How Do They Help With Claims?

Ferguson & McGuire provides full claims assistance to ensure clients receive fair and timely settlements. Their team guides policyholders through the entire process, from filing to resolution, and acts as an advocate with the insurance carrier. Whether it’s auto, home, or commercial property damage, they help minimize stress and maximize outcomes.

Claims support is available via phone, email, and in-person. Virtual tools like eSignatures streamline documentation, making the process faster and more efficient.

👥 Meet the Team

The agency is supported by experienced professionals who bring deep knowledge to every client interaction. Key team members include:

• Lisa Kelly – Account manager praised for her professionalism and skill in managing complex, multi-vehicle family insurance needs.
• Frank and Sarah – Recognized by commercial clients for their expertise in Northeast business insurance, particularly for transport and contracting firms.
• K. King and M. Discala – Licensed agents handling personal and commercial lines with a focus on client education.

The team is fluent in English and Spanish and committed to accessible, inclusive service.

⭐ What Do Clients Say About Them?

Customer feedback consistently highlights exceptional service and reliability. Chad M. commends their excellent support for small businesses. Eddie M. calls them one of the most reliable agencies in Connecticut, describing the team as “like family.”

Steven K. praised Lisa Kelly for expertly managing a complex multi-vehicle and family insurance scenario. Commercial client Xavier Auto Transport rates them as having “the best commercial insurance in the Northeast,” specifically noting Frank and Sarah for their professionalism and helpfulness.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Do they offer motorcycle and RV insurance?

Yes, Ferguson & McGuire provides motorcycle insurance and can assist with RV and recreational vehicle coverage through their network of carriers.

Are they an independent or captive agency?

They are an independent insurance broker, meaning they represent multiple carriers — not just one company — to find the best coverage and value for clients.

Can I manage my policy online?

Yes, they offer online services including video meetings, eSignatures, and virtual policy reviews, allowing you to manage your insurance remotely.

Do they serve non-English speakers?

Yes, staff members speak both English and Spanish, ensuring clear communication for a broader range of clients.

Is the office handicap accessible?

Yes, the East Hartford location is handicap accessible to ensure all clients can visit comfortably.

Editorial review: April 26, 2026 — Sources: fergusonmcguire.com, m.yelp.com, andovercompanies.com, linkedin.com, agency.nationwide.com. If you notice any inaccurate data, please report it.